Borderline Conditions and Pathological Narcissism
(Master Work Series) by Otto F. Kernberg. An in-depth
perusal of pathological narcissism and borderline personality
disorders. Narcissism is an important phase in one's personal
development. It is the foundation of a sense of self worth and
self-confidence. It is self-love in its benign form. But then,
having fulfilled its role, it is replaced by love directed at
others (object love). It is here that pathologies occur when the
individual is unable to successfully accomplish this transition.
Pathological narcissism is a lot more than a fixation on an
early developmental phase, though. This is the first weak point
of this otherwise seminal work. It is, well, fixated, on a
psychodynamic-object relations scenario. additionally, the
distinctions between borderline conditions and pathological
narcissism - both states of low organization of the personality
- are blurred. Otherwise, it is a masterpiece of hands-on
clinical work well worth perusing.
|
|
Narcissism : Denial of the True Self by
Alexander Lowen. Basic introduction to pathological narcissism,
its dynamics and treatment. "I wonder whether we read the same
book. We are, at least, very different readers. Perhaps for an
academic, Lowen's discussion of narcissism might seem narrow.
However, for the general reader, and especially for anyone who
is fascinated (or tortured) by the paradox of self-destructive
behavior, Lowen's analysis is revelatory. One does not have to
accept BioEnergetic theory in general to conclude that Lowen has
achieved some critical insights into the affliction known as
"narcissism." Rather than the state of haughty self-absorption
it is often made out to be, narcissism is in fact a form of
slavery to a false image of the self. The theory that narcissism
is actually a symptom of self-alienation, that can be relieved
by bringing the sufferer back into contact with those portions
of the self that he or she has banished, is most liberating.
Lowen makes his points using understated, elegant prose that is
more evocative of a collegial conversation than an argument.
Highly recommended to anyone who has ever been baffled by
behavior, whether of themselves or of a family member,
reflecting a combination of gross insensitivity to others,
intolerance of personal shortcomings, and a bewilderment at the
seeming aridity of life itself. Lowen has gone a long way toward
making sense of this suffering.
|
|
Culture of Narcissism : American Life in an Age of
Diminishing Expectations by Christopher Lasch. The
outlines, dynamics and faults of our narcissistic civilization.
'The Culture of Narcissism - American Life in an Age of
Diminishing Expectations' was published in the first year of the
unhappy presidency of Jimmy Carter (1979). The latter endorsed
the book publicly (in his famous 'national malaise' speech). The
main thesis of the book is that the Americans have created a
self-absorbed (though not self aware), greedy and frivolous
society which depended on consumerism, demographic studies,
opinion polls and Government to know and to define itself. What
is the solution? Lasch proposed a 'return to basics':
self-reliance, the family, nature, the community, and the
Protestant work ethic. To those who adhere, he promised an
elimination of their feelings of alienation and despair. There
is no single Lasch. This chronicler of culture, did so mainly by
chronicling his inner turmoil, conflicting ideas and ideologies,
emotional upheavals, and intellectual vicissitudes. In this
sense, of (courageous) self-documentation, Mr. Lasch epitomized
Narcissism, was the quintessential Narcissist, the better
positioned to criticize the phenomenon. Some 'scientific'
disciplines (e.g., the history of culture and History in
general) are closer to art than to the rigorous (a.k.a. 'exact'
or 'natural' or 'physical' sciences). Lasch borrowed heavily
from other, more established branches of knowledge without
paying tribute to the original, strict meaning of concepts and
terms. Such was the use that he made of 'Narcissism'. Lasch's
greatest error was that he did not acknowledge that there is an
abyss between narcissism and self love, being interested in
oneself and being obsessively preoccupied with oneself. Lasch
confuses the two. The price of progress is growing
self-awareness and with it growing pains and the pains of
growing up. It is not a loss of meaning and hope - it is just
that pain has a tendency to push everything to the background.
Those are constructive pains, signs of adjustment and
adaptation, of evolution. America has no inflated, megalomaniac,
grandiose ego. It never built an overseas empire, it is made of
dozens of ethnic immigrant groups, it strives to learn, to
emulate. Americans do not lack empathy - they are the foremost
nation of volunteers and also professes the biggest number of
(tax deductible) donation makers. Americans are not exploitative
- they are hard workers, fair players, Adam Smith-ian egoists.
They believe in Live and Let Live. They are individualists and
they believe that the individual is the source of all authority
and the universal yardstick and benchmark. This is a positive
philosophy. Granted, it led to inequalities in the distribution
of income and wealth. But then other ideologies had much worse
outcomes. Luckily, they were defeated by the human spirit, the
best manifestation of which is still democratic
capitalism.
|